Dan had the major impact in the actions of the other three characters. He did not know what he wanted, so every time he changed his mind the rest of the characters would change. For example, when he decided to tell Alice that he was seeing Anna, and Anna tells Larry. Both Anna and Dan are together, while Larry and Alice meet and have a sexual encounter. In the movie Dan is a writer, as a writer he dictates what the characters do, that is what he was doing to Alice, Anna and Larry. He was moving them around as he wanted, but at the end he ends up alone.
In this scene we have Alice (Natalie Portman) standing alone next to her picture in Anna's exposition. The dominant in this frame is Alice's picture. In this picture she looks sad because she found out that Dan had cheated on her with Anna. She is also in this scene and her pose look s as if she is disappointed and sad, just like the picture. It has been a year since she found that out, and that image is following her once again. She feels as disappointed as she was a year ago. The picture presents a flashback from that day at the loft.
The shot and camera proxemics are form far away, it is a full wide shot. You are able to see the whole background and the character. The character is not the main focus of the shot that is why she is small and with no movement. Also the lighting focuses more in the photograph than in the character, the character is just there in the darkness as if she was sad and hiding from the rest of the people in the exposition.
In the camera angle it seems as if we were looking down at the character with pity, as if we knew why she was sad. We know what happened in the scene in which the photograph was taken and in the scene that is happening know. We know her pain.
Closer is very interesting movie about love, relationships and deception. All fou actors made a great job presenting each character as they should have.
I am not sure what the photo of Alice, taken by Anna, has to do with Dan's position as the strongest character. Clarify that. The fact that he loses everything in the end might militate against your argument
ReplyDelete